“Good Man Little Faith”
The purpose of this lesson is to show how you can use the Bible
and and Biblical Studies tools in teaching other literature. The
Bible has made important contributions to British and American
literature since the earliest Anglo-Saxon works. Sometimes
tracing that influence back through earlier sources can help
understand the work itself, meaning that we have the opportunity
to apply Source Criticism from a work descended from the Bible,
as well as to the Bible itself.
I was a student as New Orleans Baptist Theological Seminary
1980-1988 studying New Testament and Greek. When I finished
there, I went to LSU for a Ph.D. in comparative literature.
Despite the fact that both fields are in literary studies, they
don't always play well together. This in spite of the fact that
any of the critical theories used in English can be used on the
Bible, and that any of the critical methods used in Biblical
Studies can be used on English texts. So I've been interested in
developing a Grand Unified Theory of Critical Theory.
In 1992, I began teaching English at Louisiana Tech. One of the
classes I taught frequently was English 102, where students
write about literature. Early on, I started teaching “Young
Goodman Brown”; I identified with Goodman Brown immediately, and
had the feeling that I had something to say about the story, but
didn't know what.
In 1998, my father gave me his copy of Pilgrim's Progress
by John Bunyan. Finally finished with my formal education, I was
in the process of reading the Great Works I'd Never Read. In
school, I only had time to read what I'd been assigned. So I was
reading books like Moby Dick, and now Pilgrim's
Progress. When I read to the chapter “Good Man Little
Faith,” I immediately recognized the similarities with “Young
Goodman Brown,” but that understates the experience. It felt
like time stopped, and I had that feeling of a first discovery,
perhaps like what Baron von Tischendorf felt when he discovered
the Codex Sinaiticus. I immediately started searching for the
article that had pointed out that Hawthorne had used Bunyan as a
model for “Young Goodman Brown,” and was delighted to find that
nobody had made this connection before. I then researched to
find out if Hawthorne was familiar with Bunyan, and was again
delighted to find out that Bunyan was one of Hawthorne's
favorite authors, and that he had even written an updated
version of Pilgrim's Progress called “The Celestial
Railroad.”
For generations, scholars agreed that Brown lost his Christian faith in the forest, based on his cry, “My [wife] Faith is gone!” In 1956, Thomas Connolly threw a clod into the punch bowl of scholarship when he argued that since the story is an allegory, Brown couldn't have lost his Christian faith because he was still married to his wife Faith. So as a class, our specific quest is to see if we can solve one of the mystery of what precisely Brown lost during his trip to the forest.
So follow the links below to see what I found out, and how I
share that with my students. Remember, these are lectures from
my 102 class, so don't worry about doing the thesis exercises
and rough draft.
- Lecture on “Young Goodman Brown.”
- Lecture on “Good Man
Little-Faith” and its source material from the Synoptics.